Menu of Lucky Duck Creamery in Waterford, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Located at 11220 Peach St, Waterford, PA, Lucky Duck Creamery stands out as a charming ice cream destination that offers both soft serve and hard packed favorites. The shop’s reputation is built on its quality ingredients, generous portions, and thoughtful variety, making it a notable choice for ice cream enthusiasts in the Erie region.

The menu highlights include the iconic flurries, and among them, the turtle flurry shines bright. Customers appreciate the rich custard base, ample syrup, and a satisfying crunch from plentiful pecans. This attention to detail sets Lucky Duck Creamery apart from other local competitors, where toppings sometimes fall short in quantity or flavor balance.

Soft serve cones are another strong suit here. Perry’s ice cream, known for its creamy texture and classic flavor, is served in large, value-packed cones that reward customers with both quality and size. Whether you prefer the chocolate and vanilla twist or a solid scoop of vanilla or chocolate, the texture is consistently smooth and refreshing.

Though some patrons mention the prices as being on the higher side, many agree that the portions and ingredient quality justify the cost. It reflects an emphasis on delivering premium indulgence rather than saving on ingredients or portion size. This is clear in the generous servings, whether it's a flurry, twist cone, or the pup cups, which also cater thoughtfully to canine companions.

Personally, the balance of flavor and portion impressed me deeply. The custard’s richness combined with fresh nuts and just the right amount of syrup creates a rewarding taste experience. The atmosphere of this small creamery exudes a welcoming vibe, perfect for families and casual outings alike. Lucky Duck Creamery manages to capture the essence of classic ice cream enjoyment while ensuring every spoonful is memorable.

Overall, if you’re seeking a blend of high-quality ingredients, fair portion sizes, and a variety of flavorful options, Lucky Duck Creamery is a must-visit. Its commitment to delivering a thoughtful ice cream experience makes it a standout spot in Waterford’s dessert scene.